Titre d’un poème de P. Celan, Schibboleth sert ici de fil conducteur pour la lecture de celui que l’on considère comme l’un des plus grands poètes de langue . Schibboleth: Für Paul Celan. Front Cover. Jacques Derrida. Passagen-Verlag, – pages Bibliographic information. QR code for Schibboleth. Schibboleth: para Paul Celan by Jacques Derrida, , available at Book Depository with free delivery worldwide.
|Published (Last):||24 September 2008|
|PDF File Size:||14.44 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||13.98 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Edit this record Mark as duplicate Export citation Find it on Scholar Request removal from index Translate to english Revision history. Not so much the philosophers who are in the United States, since there are after all many who are interested in continental philosophy.
Added to PP index Total downloads 4of 2, Recent downloads 6 months 1of 2, How can I increase my downloads? This is a move that consisted neither of accusing Heidegger of the unforgivable nor of exonerating him from his offences, but of beginning to try to understand what was going on in the reference to the spirit. I may have forgotten something in your question.
In other words, this makes the Shoah into an exception and at the same time amounts to saying that any crime, even a banal, individual crime, which is not even a genocide or extermination, as a crime against some person or against the humanity of some person, cannot be determined as crime except in relation to the “Thou shalt not kill” of the Torah, and is thus an attempt to kill the “Thou shalt not kill,” to put to death the major moral prescription, that which Levinas holds to be the major one.
He said that Jacquds was not the French Republic, that the Republic had been broken off and therefore France as such could not assume the responsibility or the guilt for the crimes against the Jews under Vichy. Every genocide takes place by reference to Mount Sinai.
It is not a philosophy of history.
Schibboleth : para Paul Celan
It’s too little, but too much. Niklas rated it liked it Jul 12, We might have chosen other examples. But obviously it is not the same as that of those who lived in Euopre, especially the preceding generation. This is very complicated, and naturally, I do not agree with this position, but that was the position he took.
Some time ago, there was held, for the first time in Jerusalem, a conference on Hannah Arendt, confronting her ideas about the Holocaust and the Eichmann trial. But this reference to the Shoah forces us in any case to ask ourselves what forgiveness means, if it is possible, deerrida it is necessary, where it comes from, what is the culture that carries the notion of forgiveness, is there forgiveness in schibbolethh where the Torah is not somehow the origin?
Deconstruction, unfortunately, is often considered to be threatening, not only in Israel, but elsewhere as well. He was judged for that, and as for me, my concern is not to exonerate him of this responsibility.
This article has no associated abstract. I went to Poland, to Auscwitz, for the first time a few weeks ago, for reasons that are related to all this. Thus there is always a possibility of either destruction or contestation of the archive and even of testimony. Nevertheless, I will try not to dodge the questions and the invitation given me. Bowlby University of Chicago Press, But, at the same time, since these are only physical records, the revisionists can always say that this was constructed, that proves nothing.
So personally, insofar as I may be determined by my own personal life, even today, I know that I do not have the same relation to the Shoah as the Jews of France, especially those of the preceding generations. Leavey, Jr and R. Unless there is a connection, in your question From Socrates to Freud and Beyondtrans. As to the question of forgiveness, of which we spoke earlier, without the Shoah having been forgotten, there may be a period of the attenuation of the suffering, a distancing of the suffering which is not a forgetting, but which is nevertheless a sort of weakening of the pain that permits other gestures.
SCHIBBOLETH NED – Jacques Derrida – Google Books
Why would it this be forbidden, to…? Does generalizing imply forgiveness? Nevertheless, is pardon an imperative? Roelof Napel rated it really liked it Oct 16, What stands out most often, even when there is interest in questions of morality, is a basic blanketing, as you were saying, a bracketing of all the events, all the traumas we’re discussing right now. And then, little by little, Hanna Arendt’s attitude during the Eichmann trial was such that Hanna Arendt was rejected.
Sarah rated it really liked it Aug 01, I could try to demonstrate, but once jaacques I can’t do it here, not under these conditions, that the concept of survival occupies an altogether particular place in my work. Forgiveness – this is what I tried to show the other night in Jerusalem at the University – pure or unconditional forgiveness must be the event or the act of a grace that cannot be commanded.
For a long time, going to Poland had been a problem for me. Paul de Man’s Wartrans. When an archive such as Yad Vashem is established and kept up, an act of piety and of memory is performed to prevent this from being erased. All these questions, that I tried to ask uacques other night, are constantly reawakened in us by the paramount reference to the Shoah.
Schibboleth : para Paul Celan : Jacques Derrida :
David rated it really liked it Jun 23, Jaxques would you defend this idea? To answer the last question, I wouldn’t say that Heidegger’s attitude is neither forgivable nor unforgivable. I don’t know to what extent one may follow Cardinal Lustiger. But that is another subject. Indeed, deconstruction is relentless in this pursuit since justice is impossible to achieve.